The Anaheim Statement: No groundswell, but some growth.

The Living Church trumptets the headline, "Anaheim Statement Continues to Gain Supporters."

It reports that 34 bishops had previously signed on and that now there were two more bishops added: Bishop Jenkins, Louisiana, who is about to retire and Bishop Harry Shipps, retired bishop of Georgia.

The existing list is as follows:

  1. The Rt. Rev’d James Adams, Western Kansas
  2. The Rt. Rev’d Lloyd Allen, Honduras
  3. The Rt. Rev’d David Alvarez, Puerto Rico FOR D025
  4. The Rt. Rev’d John Bauerschmidt, Tennessee
  5. The Rt. Rev’d Peter Beckwith, Springfield
  6. The Rt. Rev’d Frank Brookhart, Montana FOR C056 FOR D025
  7. The Rt. Rev’d Andrew Doyle, Texas
  8. The Rt. Rev’d Philip Duncan, Central Gulf Coast
  9. The Rt. Rev’d Dan Edwards, Nevada
  10. The Rt. Rev’d William Frey, Rio Grande
  11. The Rt. Rev’d Dena Harrison, Texas, Suffragan
  12. The Rt. Rev’d Dorsey Henderson, Upper South Carolina FOR C056 FOR D025
  13. The Rt. Rev’d Julio Holguin, Dominican Republic
  14. The Rt. Rev’d John Howe, Central Florida
  15. The Rt. Rev’d Russell Jacobus, Fond du Lac
  16. The Rt. Rev’d Don Johnson, West Tennessee FOR C056 FOR D025
  17. The Rt. Rev’d Paul Lambert, Dallas Suffragan
  18. The Rt. Rev’d Mark Lawrence, South Carolina
  19. The Rt. Rev’d Gary Lillibridge, West Texas
  20. The Rt. Rev’d Edward Little, Northern Indiana
  21. The Rt. Rev’d William Love, Albany
  22. The Rt. Rev’d Bruce MacPherson, Western Louisiana
  23. The Rt. Rev’d Alfredo Morante, Litoral Ecuador FOR C056
  24. The Rt. Rev’d Henry Parsley, Alabama FOR C056
  25. The Rt. Rev’d David Reed, West Texas Suffragan
  26. The Rt. Rev’d Sylvestre Romero, El Camino Real assisting in New Jersey FOR D025
  27. The Rt. Rev’d Jeffrey Rowthorn, Europe, retired
  28. The Rt. Rev’d William Skilton, Dominican Republic
  29. The Rt. Rev’d John Sloan, Alabama Suffragan FOR C056 FOR D025
  30. The Rt. Rev’d Dabney Smith, Southwest Florida
  31. The Rt. Rev’d Michael Smith, North Dakota
  32. The Rt. Rev’d James Stanton, Dallas
  33. The Rt. Rev’d Pierre Whalon, Europe FOR C056 FOR D025
  34. The Rt.Rev. Don Wimberly, Texas retired

    to that we now can add:

  35. The Rt. Rev. Charles E. Jenkins, III, Louisiana
  36. The Rt. Rev. Harry W. Shipps, retired Georgia
The Anaheim Statement among other things, reaffirmed a “commitment to the three moratoria requested of us by the Instruments of Communion." At least two of these moratoria concern actions and directives by bishops of jurisdiction, that is bishops who are the episcopal authority in the diocese.

Of the 34 who signed 25 are bishops of jurisdiction, meaning that less than one-half the number of bishops needed to deny consent to an election have pledged themselves to do so. It also means that three out of four bishops of jurisdiction in The Episcopal Church have determined that they will not in a blanket way affirm the moratoria concerning ordination of gay persons in relationship to the episcopate or refuse to consider rites for blessing of same sex couples.

The Anaheim Statement then does no more than support the conclusions of the General Convention votes on these matters: Roughly 72% -75% of bishops and deputations are not willing to affirm blanket moratoria on ordinations and blessings. This does not mean that this same percent will actually support new rites or that a majority of bishops will give consent. It only means that they will not in the abstract refuse to do so.

So there is some growth: one retired bishop to add to the list of names without power to act as regards these moratoria; one bishop about to retire. (I for one am sorry that Bishop Jenkins s retiring, although I believe he is right to do so. He is an amazing man and a fine Christian.)

Growth in the list of signers is not particularly a groundswell. It has gained supporters, but not necessarily force.


  1. I'm very sorry to see that my bishop, Charles Jenkins, added his name to the list. I was quite pleased that he had not signed the statement.

  2. We were very glad when Harry Shipps retired and took his authoritarian nonsense with him - one priest of my acquaintance was told that, for him even to be considered for postulancy to the priesthood, he'd have to go get married, and we're not talking about a situation where there was any pre-existing relationship with girlfriend, boyfriend or any other!!

    Now, if he'd just swim either the Tiber or the Golden Horn, he will have done something really useful.

  3. Mark - I don't know if it is fair to say that 3 our of 4 bishops said that they would not in a blanket way affirm the moratoria (if I'm reading what you wrote correctly). I think it might be safer to say that they have affirmed the right of all baptized people to be considered for Holy Orders. That is different than saying that during these times they will not abide by the moratoria, particularly the one about consenting to a bishop that might cause undo problems for the Communion. I hope their minds are broader than our singular parochial interests.

  4. Ooops, I guess if I read the next paragraph you covered my point. Sorry about that - I got distracted. I do want to reiterate my last sentence, however.

  5. The list of names, as you said, confirms the way things have been for a while. When I saw the list my first thought was along the lines of "yup, the usual suspects."

  6. Mark,

    Rawthorn is Europe, retired.



OK... Comments, gripes, etc welcomed, but with some cautions and one rule:
Cautions: Calling people fools, idiots, etc, will be reason to bounce your comment. Keeping in mind that in the struggles it is difficult enough to try to respect opponents, we should at least try.