Showing posts with label Jesus. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Jesus. Show all posts

8/08/2020

Make the Destination Clear: “The Episcopal Branch.of the Jesus Movement”, what does it mean?

   Make the Destination Clear: “The Episcopal branch of the Jesus Movement” – what does that mean?

 

The promo on the Episcopal Church web page for the Beloved Community” begins, “As the Episcopal branch of the Jesus Movement, we dream and work to foster Beloved Communities..”  

 

I’ve written about the notion of the Jesus Movement here” http://anglicanfuture.blogspot.com/2017/06/why-jesus-movement-movement-does-not.html

 

My concerns about the phrase “Jesus Movement” was that it has been used in very sloppy ways by a variety of people and groups that would have found The Episcopal Church to have been decidedly NOT part of its work. Any movement must be defined not just by what it moves away from (say stagnation and cooption) but by what it moves towards. That something towards which it moves is not spelled out, except by reference to fostering Beloved Communities. 

 

Beloved Communities are communities loved by someone, in this case one assumes by God. And the assumption is that by being communities of love ourselves we are reflecting God’s love and are in turn loved by God.  Beloved is a community activity, engaging both God’s actions and ours. 

 

This stuff of doing what the Lord requires - It’s a fine notion, one that I readily affirm. Micah got it, Jesus got it, the Apostles and Prophets got it, and even I’ve got it.  If that is what the Jesus Movement is – a movement fostering beloved communities – great.

 

But about the Episcopal Church being a “branch” of the Jesus Movement, I am unclear and unmoved.

 

The phrase “The Episcopal branch of the Jesus Movement” is an amazing conflation of two very different images of life in Christ – one quite institutional and the other quite individual.

 

Jesus said, “I am the vine and you are the branches.”  It is a stretch to say “branches” had anything to do with churches.  And yet there are amazing numbers of charts that show the church branches that have grown out from the tree of life (i.e. Jesus).  

 

As a teenager in New Orleans, a strongly Catholic town at the time, my priest showed me this chart with Anglican churches clearly labeled as being in continuity with the main trunk of faithful people. With some pride he talked about how we Anglicans were the third largest branch of the Church. So in spite of what those Roman Catholics would say, we are a branch of the true church.  And, just as icing on the cake, he then would reference the “I am the vine, you are the branches” statement, as if that settled the matter.  But of course it didn’t. 


It was a useful image for me as a teenager, in love (as much as I could expresse it) at that time with Roman Catholic young woman. It gave me talking points in conversations about our religious beliefs.  IT kind of gave me a pedigree.

 

The reference, “The Episcopal branch” is a hint back to the assurance that what we are about is both part of the core activity of being followers of Jesus, and being part of the “true” church.  May it be so.

 

But the problem is that the Jesus Movement, which is not apparently an edifice or tree or vine or any other definable organized entity, is that it is not something that has branches.  It is not an organization (like say a bank) that has branch offices. It is not a tree or vine organized as a living organism that has tendrils or new growth extensions.

 

I believe the Jesus Movement is an aspirational and spiritual declaration, and as a result, it is part of the personal side of the baptismal covenant.  The individual (I) joins this movement towards belonging to and engaging with the beloved community. But the beloved community is itself “not of this world.”  It is not an organized entity of any sort. Rather beloved community is found as we gather in a whole variety of ways to live out what Moses, Micah, other prophets, and  Jesus (and a whole host of others) point us towards. 

 

The notion that The Episcopal Church is a “branch” of some ongoing historical organization called “the One, Holy, Catholic and Apostolic Church” is an institutional claim.  But what is it to say we are a branch of the Jesus Movement? I think it means almost nothing.

 

Fostering beloved communities is not the same as establishing new communities that will somehow BE beloved communities. We can foster beloved communities in every parish in the church, but the funds for such efforts tend to go to “new” work, not to support of already existing parishes so that they become agents of new community. The new work being funded looks increasingly parallel to, but not included in, the ongoing effort to foster beloved community IN parishes.  Giles Fraser in an article posted this week https://unherd.com/2020/08/the-neoliberal-revolution-within-the-church/

points to a similar dynamic in the Church of England.

 

Episcopalians can be, and I hope are, part of the Jesus Movement. I hope I am. I hope we take our baptismal vows seriously. And I believe I am not the vine, but a really small tendril from that vine, one of the followers of Jesus.

 

But the Episcopal Church is not such a branch. People are.

 

So when there is this rush to do “new work” we in the church may be told that this is all about being the Episcopal branch of the Jesus Movement, but don’t believe it.  It may indeed be about doing or supporting very important and good work “fostering beloved community.” Those ongoing communities of faithful people gathered in congregations across the land will be mostly left out of the conversation.

 

Existing parishes will mostly be left to their own devices, the bigger and better off will make it. The smaller and less financially capable will mostly die off.  And new work will be mostly unrelated to the institutional Church at all.  The branch of the tree may whither even as new shoots are planted. 

 

All of this may be part of moving on, and if so let it be. But don’t mutter about the Episcopal part of the Jesus Movement. I am not at all sure that there will be any need for bishops in the Jesus Movement at all, much less The Episcopal Church. 

 

Time to clean up the language, or else, to use Fr. Fraser’s insight)  face into the new-liberal deconstruction of the church as we now know it.

 

I believe we need to make the destination clear.  If the call to be the Episcopal branch of the Jesus Movement is a post-denominational claim or an extra-institutional claim, then be clear that what we are asked to join and support is not new work of The Episcopal Church but rather the work of Jesus people moving on towards the realization of the beloved community. This is the new wine, new wine skin crowd. . If we are The Episcopal Church AS an organization fostering Beloved Community in our own corporate life, perhaps we might better start by helping existing communities to be more like the communities we are called to be. This is the crowd that seeks to be born again, even when old. 

 

Me, I’d like to see the church that perpetually seeks a rebirth of wonder. (To cop a phrase from Lawrence Ferlinghetti).  But if it must be, get a new wine skin for new wine.

 

Either way: Make the path clear.

 

11/20/2017

The Venom of the Serpent is not enough.

( This is my first sermon after a year away from preaching at the three main services at St. Peter’s, Lewes. A lot happened in a year, both in the world and in my own life. Much of the “world” year has been filled with venom. Much of my personal year has been filled with grace. This sermon is written against the backdrop of my year with cancer and my year surrounded by love and care from all sides. It was preached on the 51st anniversary of marriage to Kathryn. So it is a time when I am very conscious of the abundance of life even in a venomous world.)


THE VENOM OF THE SERPENT IS NOT ENOUGH.

A Sermon by Mark Harris, November 19, 2017, St. Peter’s, Lewes, Delaware.

May we not be left in a place of weeping and gnashing of teeth. Amen.

The present seems very much a time in which people tear each other down, 
look for the sin in every soul, 
the evil in every politician, 
Where the ends are sought for which any means are justified.  

That is, the present seems to be a time where we feel it necessary to be very self-protective, self-justifying and in which we take care of ourselves first and last.  You remember Jesus’ comment, that we should be as wise as serpents, as innocent as doves?  We work at being wise as serpents. As innocent as doves?  Not so much. It seems a time when we only seek to be snakes, and particularly to be venomous snakes.

You all know what I am talking about: 
We lived with the spirit of tearing down, 
not building up, 
the spirit for destruction, 
not construction. 

I confess a certain perverse interest in getting all the scoop on just how bad it all is, and I vacillate between delighting in the fallenness or thick headed ness of leaders and despairing the general state of things. But I live knowing that what I’m mostly doing is tearing down.

Of course there is a good bit of that tearing down that is well deserved. 
• Too many men have been treating women as objects, with disdain and disrespect, 
• too many politicians have covered up too much from their constituents, and have made too many deals to keep themselves in office,
• too many white people have been too oppressive to people of color
• Too many adults have been cruel of too many children, and the children in turn have learned to be cruel to one another.

And so on….

And catching the various perps out is needed. So we do. But it also becomes delicious to do, since it feeds our real sense that it is a time of destruction, in which we too can be destroyers. We grow to love spitting righteous venom.

And of course it is true not only in civil community. It is true in our religious communities as well.  There are lots of disaffected Christians floating around out there, disturbed, and often appropriately so, by the sins and degradations of those who lead in the church.

It turns out that sin and degradation is everywhere present, and if we are not careful that is all we see, and seeing sin and degradation, we make our decisions with venomous calculation. When we do that we begin to enjoy the possibility of the whole thing crashing down.

That however is a terrible way to live. 

If we live by the venom of the snake of sin and degradation, we will die by that same venom. Taking on the wrath, even the wrath of God, as our primary way of being in the world is finally to make vengeance our byword and mutually assured destruction becomes our end. The hand that slaps the offender comes around and slaps us, for we are all sinners.

That is why the admonition of Paul to the Thessalonians is so important. 

“put on the breastplate of faith and love, and for a helmet the hope of salvation. For God has destined us not for wrath but for obtaining salvation through our Lord Jesus Christ.”

 We put on faith, love, and hope of salvation. In the face of universal damnation, we live with things eternal, Faith, hope and love, and as Paul says in First Corinthians, the greatest of these is Love. Remember thing things of venom do not last, are not eternal, but the things of faith, hope and love, they do. 

Paul writes, “Therefore encourage one another and build up each other, as indeed you are doing.”  And so we ought to do as well.

Jesus ends this remarkable parable we read this morning with the odd and deeply disturbing comment : “For to all those who have, more will be given, and they will have an abundance; but from those who have nothing, even what they have will be taken away.” There is a lot to unpack in this parable.  But I want to note one thing:

What did the first two servants have that the third did not? The first two took what was given and saw it as something to build up, to encourage, something on which to expand. The third saw only the possibilities of failure at the hands of a venomous landlord. He saw poison, and in fear acted in a way that was surely going to poison the relation he had with the landlord. The end result was that the little he had was taken from him. The third servant believed he had nothing, so the little he did have (and he did have something) was useless. His world became an outer darkness,  one of weeping and gnashing of teeth. And we too will live in such outer darkness if we live only in fear.

It seems clear: All the gloom and doom that we see, the vision of sin and meanness and greed and the fear that accompanies it – if that is all we see and experience, then we will be blind in the gloom. It will be hard to mobilize for new action. We will do nothing that endures. 

If on the other hand we take what is given, and find a way through the gloom and doom of personal and corporate sinfulness, we enter a new place, a place of refreshment and new life. We do not have to live forever with venom as our only shield. Love and its abundance is a better way.

That is why the readings this morning are important for NOW.  Now is a time of great dread, the time of darkness. But if that is what we see, and only what we see, then we miss the abundance that is also there, is always there, for that which endures is of that abundance. 

This is not a Pollyanna sort of observation. I don’t think I’m a Pollyanna sort of person. Some even suggest that I have an edge of sarcasm and rough realism.  Rather I believe this is a realistic healing observation. 

The healing of the world begins and ends in acts of faith, hope and love. It does not begin and end in venom, even the venom of the self-protecting snake. It is those acts of faith, hope and love that endure. It is there that we must cast our vision and our work.

What this means for our little community of Christians here in Lewes is this: we need to connect to others primarily with faith, hope and love as our guides, not distrust, guile and hate. 

There will always be the need to be wise as serpents, but we need to teach the serpent in us not to be venomous. And some doves of peace might be in order.

We do not need to poison relationships, even with those who are, in our eyes, wrong or stupid or heretical or just plain boring. When we have reasons, good reasons, to disagree we need to find ways to not become disagreeable, nasty and venomous in the process, for then what little humanity we have will be taken away. And we will live in the land of weeping and gnashing of teeth. Not a pleasant possibility!

All of which calls to mind another epistle, that to the Philippians, where Paul writes,

In your relationships with one another, have the same mindset as Christ Jesus:

Who, being in very nature God,
did not consider equality with God something to be used to his own advantage;
rather, he made himself nothing
by taking the very nature of a servant,
being made in human likeness.
And being found in appearance as a man,
he humbled himself
by becoming obedient to death—
even death on a cross!”

Our obedience may not be as great as that of our Lord, but it is there. Our obedience begins by bringing out in one another all that is good and right, by lifting up and encouraging one another, not by bringing one another down. And if that means we take the form of a servant, suffering the foolishness of this age, it is a small cross for that which will endure.

And that’s what I know about the Gospel today. Amen.



1/02/2016

Why Incarnation is Essential: Incarnation, take #2

(This is a rather long and awkward essay, but I am trying to put in words my sense that beyond my sometimes glib use of the word “God” lies the belief that the reality at the core of the universe is a reality that can be appropriated by self-aware beings (humans for example) as a source of meaning in our several lives. The reader will, I hope, forgive the failings of this effort.)



Why Incarnation is Essential.



‘God’ is a shorthand word



‘God’ is, for me, a shorthand word. It is a marker for that reality that lies at the center of my faith that existence has purpose, meaning or even direction. I use the word all the time, often as if it were a name of a person, one who had feelings much as any human would – feelings of caring, loving, anger and the like. There is a long tradition for ascribing to God those sorts of feelings.  But when I do so I am often uneasy, for the shorthand word ‘God’ is about a reality that is far distant from the specifics of the day and the time, much less the person that is me, and distant too from (merely) human feeling. The reality that lies at the center of my faith is not, however, a person, not even a god (as we normally think of gods). This reality is something like ‘the Word,’ as used in the beginning of the Gospel of John.


The Word, the Big Bang, and everything else


I believe that the universe and all that is in it had a beginning and will have an end, and that both those events are entirely abstract for me, being events on the edge of creation. I believe that the movement from one to the other – from beginning to end – is not random. Rather the opportunities in that movement, often described after the fact as ‘chance,’ betray a predilection for complexity. And that complexity exhibits patterns and elements of design. That is, the development of the universe and then in a microcosm the development of this planet, give way to complexity and to greater and greater levels of organization.
the separation of the waters. woodblock 2015
Each branching into to new forms of material reality seems to involve chance or organization by continuous but always partial adaptation. But the overall movement is startling in its ‘arc,’ an arc that seems to bend towards a universe increasingly aware of its own development, as signaled by the self awareness that humans have. We humans are self-aware, and It may well be that the universe is itself self-aware.  It may also be that human self-awareness is but a shadow of some higher sense of unity that the whole of existence shares in a pre or post cognitive way. 



Choosing to believe


Still, it seems the faith choice is there: either I chose to believe that there is intelligence, or better, awareness, attached to the arc of events that are the history of the universe, or I don't.  Either I chose to believe there is purpose, meaning and value to that arc, or I do not. So I chose to believe the universe is developing in a way that signals meaning and intelligence.  I do not chose to believe that randomness prevails.



‘God’ becomes the shorthand word for that intelligence, location of meaning, and purpose.



That God, the God that lies behind the sense I have of intelligence, meaning and purpose in all that is, I also call ‘the Creator,’ and the unfolding events in the history of the universe is the creation.
The source of Awe, recipient of my gratitude


I’ve become more and more aware of just how difficult is it to do more than stand in awe of the Creator and the Creation both. I become aware too that creation is an ongoing activity. Creation is not about “then,” is it about “now.” Everything is held together now by the same Source that gives meaning and purpose from the beginning. There are no adequate ways to talk about any characteristics of that Source of meaning. About all I can do is experience the creation at this moment, and in the moment be filled with gratitude.  I realize that in part my ability to be thankful, filled with gratitude, is a result of finding enough about existence that is enjoyable to carry me into a place of joyfulness.  For those who experience existence as bleak, where beauty is absent and struggles meaningless, gratitude and thankfulness is hard to come by.



I have a personal relationship with the Creator God in that I believe the experience of joy is itself from the same source that bends what exists to its own journey to completion. But that personal relationship is with God who “so loves the world,” not with God who particularly loves me. My gratitude to the Creator God is for the creation and the enjoyment of that creation.  God the Creator is just too distant from the joys and strife of the particular to be much of a companion. The Creator God loves the creation, and so loves me. But I don’t directly experience that love, except to the extent that I am grateful for the wonder of creation. I experience that wonder and revel in the knowledge that the Source loves what is created.


I bend to the arc

I do not think it is of much help to go to this Creator God for help in times of trouble. The arc is just too great, the issues just too big, and I am too small and specific, for the Creator God to be aware of me in my specificity. I bend to the arc, the arc does not bend to me.   I do not pray to the Creator for relief, I pray in response to gratitude. And while I can imagine this gratitude as putting me in harmony with the Creator’s larger work, I find it hard to imagine that work including specifics about my troublesome responses to day to day challenges in my life.



I am and feel finite. The span of years of the universe is one thing, my span is quite another. I am very aware that my coming into and going out of the “world,” that is, in an out of existence as a material thing, is a reality central to me, but not, in its particulars, to that source and core intelligence to which I stand in awe and gratitude.


When I find myself in times of trouble


When I find myself in times of trouble I need love in a much more personal way than can be offered (at least as far as I know) by the source and maker of all things. I need love in my troubles, care in my pain, understanding for my fears, a comforting and sometimes challenging response from someone as real and as present as I am.  I do not need explanation as to how we all fit into the great chain of being, in the natural patterns, in the unfolding of God’s great creative energy. That is a general comfort to me as I bend my arc to meet the arc of the universe. But it is no comfort on a cold night, or in times of pain or fear, or even the calm observation of declining abilities and powers that comes with age.  The Source of Creation is no consolation when my love is unrequited, or my friendships thwarted, or when my loneliness is not about being alone, but being unloved. In those troubles I need local and specific love, represented in body present with my body, soul with my soul. I need a sister, brother, lover, friend.



I need, in other words, a local outcropping of the spiritual presence of meaning and value in tangible form. I need an incarnation of that source of purpose and meaning as a source of comfort and challenge now.



Incarnation: the Word in a body like mine


There are people who know the reality of that great arc, the creative movement by which the universe has a beginning and end, purpose and intelligence, and which is a source of awe and beauty. Some of them bring that reality with them into the effort to stand with others, including me, in times of joy and sorrow both. They whisper, “do not be afraid.” They know fear themselves. They sit with me in my sufferings, physical and spiritual, and without excuse or avoidance they weave my local reality into the greater story, the higher arc. They do this because for greater or lesser time they are the incarnation of the Word in a body like mine. They are the incarnation of Creator taking the consequences for creation.



All created beings last for a while only, and the more aware they are of that fact the more important it is for that awareness to be borne with others. When someone bears the burdens of existence with me, for me, on account of me, it become an outward and visible sign that there is some echo of the great arc of Creation in the small arc of my life.



In the great story, the source of meaning, purpose and intelligence is increasingly known as the universe completes its unfolding, and we gaze on it in awe and wonder.   In my small arc birth and death are the markers for a creative span, an arc, that is distinctly my own. Just as I stand in awe and wonder and thanksgiving in the face of the whole creation, so it is possible similarly to stand before my own life. What the incarnate ones do is affirm me, in my short arc, as having meaning, purpose, and wonder somewhat like that held by the whole.  The incarnate ones apply the Word to me. They are the Word for me. And they do so with a body like mine. They do so with an arc that is small, and often lived out alone.


The Incarnation of the Word in Jesus.


The incarnate ones are persons who in this moment or that mirror, reflect, embody, what I understand and believe is present in the Source of all that is, namely a sense of purpose and design regarding the ongoing creative enterprise. There is an arc in time bending towards greater complexity and then to self awareness and ultimately to completion. Some people incarnate that in their own sense of meaning, and reflect that outward to those around them. These are the ones we seek when we are troubled. They stand with us and by us and for us.



Most incarnate ones are only that for brief times, sometimes brief moments. When they are incarnate they are the presence of the Holy, and their comfort is a holy comfort. They are, for their brief moments, the Word made flesh.



I believe that Jesus is such an incarnate one, but that in him “all the fullness of God was pleased to dwell.” He is the incarnation of the Word not for this moment or that but in the whole of his being.  His vital signs are immensely important. That he laughed and cried, danced and died, felt pain and pleasure, looked in awe at the stars and in horror at the way people could treat one another, are all vitally important, for they affirm that he was “as we are.”  And he bent the arc towards God the Creator’s ends.


How the fullness of the Word is incarnate after Jesus


His incarnation now is in the greater complexity of his risen self, which self is given flesh – incarnated – in a community of the Spirit.  This community consists of all of us who understand ourselves to be part of the body of Christ and who stand with and for those who find themselves in times of trouble. That community is not the church, it does not necessarily consist of Christians, but it is filled with people who love as Jesus did, aware of God’s reach and purpose in all things.



And we share in the incarnation, in our little moments, and can collectively stand for every moment, as a sign that the awe and wonder we have in the whole created universe is an awe that is present in each of us, and that purpose and meaning and delight are to be found in every atom of creation, in every thing that exists, and most particularly in every being that has found self-awareness. The wonder that is in creation is in us as well.



Jesus is the Word made flesh, and we now, indeed we, all of humanity, are the carriers of that Word.  Jesus loves us, affirming us as God’s own creation, part of the larger arc bending towards fulfillment, and calls us to affirm one another by that same love.



Incarnation then is the essential affirmation that the Creator and the Word are not distant from our short and often difficult lives, but rather as close as our love for one another, a love we know fully and well in Jesus.



Incarnation is essential to faith. It is the details that will derange us at times. To experience the awe in contemplating the universe, its beginning growing complexitgy and end and to experience the awe in birth, life and death, are related. Words are hard to come by to express that relation, but the closest sorts of words are love and joy and awe. They are probably enough.