12/01/2015
Flogging the dead horse "Anglican Covenant,"
So the Anglican Covenant is being touted again as a way forward in deepening communion. Who knows if the Primates meeting will take up again the somewhat tattered and torn text of the Anglican Covenant. Who knows if that meeting will pay attention to TLC's editorial opinion concerning their work. We shall see.
I believe the replay of the Anglican Covenant, in its current form, by the Primates in particular, is unwise.
There are several really bad ideas that make their way into this essay and its arguments for a preferential option (whatever that is):
(i) The notion of a "Preferential option" by the Primates for the Anglican Covenant makes it appear that somehow the Primates could decide on their own to declare for the Anglican Covenant. I suppose they could. But they cannot declare for their churches. Oh, in some Provinces where the Primate exercises extraordinary executive authority, I suppose they could. But most Churches are guided in polity questions by some sort of synodical processes. So a "Primatial Option" would be the opinion of the primates. Unless it were a unanimous vote for support it would simply affirm that the Anglican Communion is no where near a place of agreement on the Anglican Covenant. Most disturbing is the idea that this title puts forth: namely that a "Primatial option" even exists. There is no common agreement that statements by the Primates on any matter stand separate from the ACC and the decisions by the member churches. "Primatial option" is a really bad idea. It smacks of a primatial preemption.
(ii) The Essay quotes the Lambeth Quadrilateral on the need for "common Faith and Order, to discountenance schism, to heal the wounds of the Body of Christ, and to promote the charity which is the chief of Christian graces and the visible manifestation of Christ to the world." This is a worthy end, but common Faith and Order, I believe, did not include any suggestion of commonality in all things. It concerned core Christian belief and ordering of ministry. Thus the Lambeth Quadrilateral's markers for such faith and order were to be found in Scripture, the Sacraments, the Creeds and the Episcopate, described in simple straightforward terms.
Matters of the interpretation of Scripture, the rites for or teaching about the sacraments, the use of the Creed in worship or changes reflecting ecumenical agreement about the proper wording of any creed, or a particular use of episcopal authority, up to and including the extent to which the "head" of a particular church is understood to be a Primate at all, are without doubt ecumenical in consequence and to be taken with due care, but the ecumenical world (in this instance) includes the world of Anglican Provinces themselves.
That is, the Anglican Communion is in the first instance an example of the ecumenical union for which the Lambeth Quadrilateral was proposed as a model. The Anglican Communion is not a world wide church. It is an ecumenical and familial union of churches all who share the signs of union at their core and who form their lives in accordance with the peoples and nations in which they find themselves.
(iii) The Essay would have us think otherwise. It speaks of unity and diversity and quotes the Windsor Report, which speaks of the limits of diversity. The Essay opines that there is "an important caveat or “fundamental limit,” to autonomy, namely, communion itself. As The Windsor Report said: “Communion is, in fact, the fundamental limit to autonomy” (§ 82)."
None but the truly Anglican nerd types even bother to quote the Windsor Report any more. And one of the reasons is precisely this sort of statement. When the Windsor Report states, "Communion is, in fact, the fundamental limit to autonomy," it is harping on the seemingly commendable notion that the actions of one church, community, province, or whatever, in Christ, ought to put aside its own preferences when such preferences would lead others to sin, a chief sin being to break communion. Communion (and its continuity) trumps autonomous action on matters even of great concern. Most of this line of thinking grows from comments about individuals and being stumbling blocks.
The problem is that this guide for our exercise of freedom in Christ - that we give way in order to maintain communion - was primarily a rule about my behavior and yours as individuals. It works pretty well on that level. But it is less helpful on the level of Church polity. On the level of church polity it is hopeless.
Suppose we were to apply the notion that "communion is in fact the fundamental limit to autonomy" to a diocesan convention where there is a heated discussion about capital punishment (currently in the state where that diocese is situated the law of the land). After much discussion a vote is to be taken, and it appears from polling of delegates that a resolution against capital punishment will pass by a sizable majority. Some one opposed to this, believing that the current laws are appropriate, rises and says, "if this passes there will be a break in this Diocese, and I will lead those who cannot agree out and we will not participate in the life of the Diocese. We will withdraw from communion with this Diocese. The only way to keep us together is to defeat this resolution."
One could argue that the proponents of the legislation, those opposed to capital punishment, ought to give way until another time, when the arguments might carry greater weight, or new arguments found. This would be placing communion before autonomy. Autonomy, in this case, is expressed by the representative action and will of the body of the synod - not the consensus action, but the representative action. Of course representative action leads to that awful thing, the autonomous will of the body. Not the totally convinced will, but the will none the less.
In such circumstances the argument for the limits to autonomy in communion being communion itself totally sidesteps the notion that we are not dealing with individuals here, but bodies of people who vote on matters in some representative way. When decision get made, they sometimes build stronger communion, and sometimes not. But they get made anyway. The Windsor Report needs to be put to rest. Its argument for communion as the limit to autonomy in communion is logic chopping.
The Primates Meetings have a particular place in the life of the Anglican Communion. They are a late invention, but because they involve the heads of churches they have gradually taken on more and more authority. They have little power but considerable collective authority. They have become the place where the outward and visible signs of communion (or the lack thereof) are most obvious. When some primates refused to receive communion with others, or stayed away entirely, their absence reduced the authority of the Primates common voice. But that authority does not translate well into power. Power has its own venue in Anglican land, primarily in the synods of the various churches. I suspect the authority of the Primates will not find common expression concerning the Anglican Covenant, even if the Archbishop of Canterbury were to push it. But for sure that expression will fall on less sympathetic ears in some Provinces when the Primates views, whatever they are, come home to the synods of the Churches for confirmation, ratification, or whatever one might do with Primatial options.
The Living Church has become a wonderful resource for the whole church and its stances on various matters requires considerable thought. I admire the Editor and his work and the writers of TLC, and consider myself honored by occasional opportunity to write for its pages. I believe TLC's suggestion of a "Primatial option" needs to be read carefully. My critique comes from my esteem. I hope better critique is made, but this is a start.
In sum, whatever else happens to the Anglican Covenant, I hope the Primates will spend as little time in trying to revive the horse as possible and more time in such difficult tasks as looking to common core concerns.
2/21/2007
Gradualism is trembling ground.
This article in the Guardian, titled, Unity over integrity, ends with the following:
"Dr Williams' gradualist intention is to manage this divergence of beliefs. But there is nothing uplifting about the consequences. In the end he can do little to stop the separation, as the nominal figurehead of a movement whose members have acquired a confidence that has moved beyond their roots in the British empire. Anglicanism is evolving into two forms of protestantism: a scriptural conservatism and a more free-thinking search for modern spiritual guidance. Both have their adherents. Neither pays much attention to Dr Williams. He may not have to struggle to keep them together for much longer."
Mark Chapman notes, "Different churches across the globe can develop very different ways of thinking about God and his relations with the world. With its history of autonomous action and its absence of central authority, except at a very rudimentary level, Anglicanism has always been particularly prone to ever-increasing diversity." (Anglicanism, a Very Short Introduction ,Oxford, 2006, p 12).
The possible separation may reflect the genuinely felt differences in "thinking about God and his relations with the world." If so integrity lies there. There is no shame in coming down on one side or the other of such a fault line…it runs through here, and indeed through every church community. The shame may be in trying to make unity the place where one's integrity is lodged.
Archbishop Williams is a quite remarkable person and carrying a load no one ought to bear. It seems he feels he has been placed where he is to bear the marks of suffering for unity. That suffering has become, it seems, his integrity.
But unity has already been established in Jesus Christ. The unity of the Anglican Communion as a regulatory agency is not the unity that Our Lord prayed for. That unity is relational, not confessional. The Creator and The Annointed One are one in relation. Surely the Archbishop's integrity of person and position can be relational as well. Unity is not the cause for which he must suffer. My prayer is that he can let it go.
The unity of the Anglican Communion may be let go of as easily as breathing out. When it came into being, it was relational. It has existed relationally. Perhaps even in its disunity it can still be relational.
2/16/2007
A Martyr Shepherd.
How are we to address the nature of his witness? The Global South web pages posts his remembrance this way: "He would not compromise on Biblical truth and he paid the ultimate price." GS Website also gives the date as February 16th, the last time he was seen alive. The date in Lesser Feasts and fasts is set for the 17th. The story referenced in this short statement by the GS Web pages does not speak to that aspect of his courage but rather to his pastoral courage in confronting the power of the State in the person of the President Idi Amin.
This is what the biographical sketch says: "The Archbishop called on President Amin to deliver a note of protest, signed by nearly all the bishops of Uganda, against the policies of arbitrary killings and the unexplained disappearances of many persons. Amin accused the Archbishop of treason, produced a document supposedly by former President Obote attesting his guilt, and had the Archbishop and two Cabinet members (both committed Christians) arrested and held for military trial.
On 16 February, the Archbishop and six bishops were tried on a charge of smuggling arms. Archbishop Luwum was not allowed to reply, but shook his head in denial. The President concluded by asking the crowd: "What shall we do with these traitors?" The soldiers replied "Kill him now". The Archbishop was separated from his bishops. As he was taken away Archbishop Luwum turned to his brother bishops and said: "Do not be afraid. I see God's hand in this."
The three (the Archbishop and the two Cabinet members) met briefly with four other prisoners who were awaiting execution, and were permitted to pray with them briefly."There is no doubt that the Archbishop was convinced and convicted by his faith that that that faith was biblically based. Was that a matter of not compromising on "biblical truth?" Yes of course if what is meant by biblical truth is justice for the poor and the oppressed, care for those in prison, praying with those about to be executed and suffering for that faith and witness.
In this sense we are all on the same side. "Biblical truth" is the light of God's Word shown through the biblical witness on to our lives and giving us the light of Christ to live by.
One wonders what Archbishop Luwum would think of the use of "biblical truth" as applied to those who reference it in these days to condemn others of the Faith.
I have prayed at his memorial in Kampala. St. Thomas Church, Newark, Delaware, where the Moderator was once Rector and I was associate, while on staff at the Church Center, has a stained glass window remembering him. The Rector was instrumental in getting the window installed. One of the Archbishops successors visited the church to see the window. His current successor, and the Moderator will not receive communion with the Presiding Bishop of the Episcopal Church, on whose Executive Council I serve.
I find this sad beyond all measure. Well, I am sure we all will pray from the collect:
"Grant us to be so inspired by his witness that we make no peace with oppression, but live as those who are sealed with the cross of Christ, who died and rose again, and now lives and reigns with you and the Holy Spirit, one God, for ever and ever. Amen."
Someone has pointed me to the Episcopal News Service and the note there of a moment of some unity reached around the memory of the Archbishop.
"In other activities, Ugandan Archbishop Henry Orombi led a prayer service commemorating the anniversary of the death of Janani Luwum, African martyr and former Archbishop of the Church of Uganda, who was murdered in 1977 under dictator Idi Amin's regime.
The Archbishop of York, Dr. John Sentamu, who escaped Amin's rule in 1974, read two prayers. 'Both were under the pastoral care of Janani Luwum," Canon James Rosenthal, communications director of the Anglican Communion, told reporters. Jefferts Schori read a lesson as part of the commemoration.'"
There are moments of grace.
The Lord's Table revisited.
SITTING AT THE LORD'S TABLE: ,Statement from Global South Primates
The title is now stated this way:
SITTING AT THE LORD'S TABLE: Primates explain absence at Holy Eucharist
It would appear that someone got to the editor and explained that the Global South Primates (as a group) did not make a statement, nor did the GS Steering Committee.
The second title reflects my earlier observations.
The Primates who have notably engaged in ministry in a jurisdiction not their own were absent from the Holy Eucharist.
This is an entirely different story.